Model Performance Evaluation (MPE) PM2.5 d04 (2009013000-2009020100)

CAMSID   AVG  METHOD NDATA  MEAN_M  MEAN_O STDDEV_M STDDEV_O SLOPE  OFFSET       R  G_BIAS   G_ERR  G_RMSE   G_SDE     IOA

 Total         B-FIT   682   18.78    8.82    9.35    5.84    0.93   10.57    0.58    9.97   10.29   12.54    7.62    0.52
               EXACT   682   23.27    8.82   12.14    5.84    1.01   14.34    0.49   14.46   14.91   17.93   10.61    0.39

     1   1hr   B-FIT    49   22.95    9.65   10.99    5.98    1.45    8.94    0.79   13.29   13.31   15.11    7.19    0.51
               EXACT    49   29.03    9.65   15.75    5.98    2.30    6.78    0.88   19.38   19.38   22.18   10.80    0.44
        24hr   B-FIT    45   22.62    9.02    4.36    2.22    1.83    6.08    0.94   13.60   13.60   13.81    2.38    0.28
               EXACT    45   29.51    9.02   16.33    2.22    0.22   27.50    0.03   20.49   20.68   26.14   16.23    0.11
     8   1hr   B-FIT    49   23.94    9.14    8.12    6.60    0.63   18.16    0.51   14.80   14.83   16.50    7.30    0.44
               EXACT    49   29.31    9.14    8.29    6.60    0.49   24.87    0.39   20.17   20.17   21.80    8.27    0.34
        24hr   B-FIT    45   25.80    8.88    3.13    1.99   -1.04   35.01   -0.66   16.92   16.92   17.55    4.64    0.14
               EXACT    45   28.96    8.88    8.53    1.99   -1.24   40.02   -0.29   20.08   20.14   22.09    9.20    0.11
    15   1hr   B-FIT    49   19.99    9.30    9.31    7.17    1.06   10.11    0.82   10.70   10.70   11.95    5.32    0.63
               EXACT    49   26.82    9.30   10.77    7.17    1.14   16.23    0.76   17.53   17.53   18.88    7.02    0.48
        24hr   B-FIT    45   19.43    9.04    4.26    2.06    1.90    2.22    0.92   10.39   10.39   10.68    2.47    0.32
               EXACT    45   27.23    9.04   11.11    2.06    0.07   26.61    0.01   18.19   18.40   21.33   11.15    0.13
    35   1hr   B-FIT    49   18.63    9.13    8.65    5.20    1.25    7.26    0.75    9.51    9.51   11.14    5.81    0.55
               EXACT    49   28.14    9.13   11.68    5.20    1.04   18.65    0.46   19.01   19.11   21.59   10.25    0.31
        24hr   B-FIT    45   17.49    8.54    3.82    1.86    0.20   15.77    0.10    8.95    8.95    9.82    4.04    0.21
               EXACT    45   28.86    8.54   11.87    1.86   -0.99   37.34   -0.16   20.32   20.32   23.68   12.16    0.08
    45   1hr   B-FIT    49   16.05    7.89    7.01    4.41    1.08    7.52    0.68    8.16    8.20    9.63    5.10    0.52
               EXACT    49   19.27    7.89    8.02    4.41    1.17   10.04    0.64   11.38   11.48   12.93    6.12    0.43
        24hr   B-FIT    45   15.28    6.80    3.44    1.32    1.23    6.88    0.47    8.48    8.48    9.00    3.01    0.22
               EXACT    45   19.68    6.80    8.25    1.32    0.87   13.79    0.14   12.88   12.88   15.20    8.08    0.13
    64   1hr   B-FIT    47   14.33    8.96    6.44    8.22    0.32   11.42    0.41    5.37    7.69    9.62    8.31    0.56
               EXACT    47   15.42    8.96    6.62    8.22    0.16   13.98    0.20    6.46    9.52   11.38    9.86    0.42
        24hr   B-FIT    45   12.07    7.92    1.91    2.80    0.50    8.09    0.74    4.15    4.15    4.55    1.88    0.57
               EXACT    45   15.21    7.92    7.16    2.80   -0.28   17.42   -0.11    7.29    9.71   10.73    8.24    0.26
    78   1hr   B-FIT    49   18.65    6.99    6.53    5.52    0.33   16.36    0.28   11.66   12.47   13.71    7.25    0.32
               EXACT    49   22.32    6.99    9.96    5.52    0.10   21.62    0.05   15.33   16.46   18.87   11.06    0.19
        24hr   B-FIT    45   19.59    6.25    2.54    1.36   -1.42   28.45   -0.76   13.33   13.33   13.82    3.64    0.11
               EXACT    45   21.64    6.25   10.11    1.36    0.14   20.78    0.02   15.38   15.79   18.38   10.07    0.09
   303   1hr   B-FIT    47   13.96   10.25    6.69    6.22    0.80    5.77    0.74    3.72    4.21    5.90    4.62    0.79
               EXACT    47   16.81   10.25    6.32    6.22    0.58   10.85    0.57    6.56    7.43    8.72    5.80    0.63
        24hr   B-FIT    45   12.43    8.90    3.13    2.15    0.98    3.69    0.68    3.53    3.58    4.21    2.28    0.57
               EXACT    45   16.71    8.90    6.58    2.15    0.24   14.59    0.08    7.82    9.23   10.29    6.84    0.28
   304   1hr   B-FIT    49   24.08    9.53   11.85    5.64    1.73    7.60    0.82   14.55   14.55   16.51    7.79    0.49
               EXACT    49   27.64    9.53   13.43    5.64    2.00    8.63    0.84   18.12   18.12   20.28    9.13    0.44
        24hr   B-FIT    45   22.92    8.78    5.37    2.26    2.27    2.97    0.96   14.14   14.14   14.50    3.23    0.28
               EXACT    45   28.10    8.78   13.90    2.26    2.02   10.40    0.33   19.32   19.32   23.38   13.18    0.15
   309   1hr   B-FIT    49   22.94    7.86    8.28    5.02    0.91   15.79    0.55   15.08   15.08   16.56    6.85    0.38
               EXACT    49   27.56    7.86   10.98    5.02    1.05   19.27    0.48   19.70   19.70   21.88    9.52    0.29
        24hr   B-FIT    45   24.48    7.43    2.85    1.54   -1.27   33.91   -0.69   17.05   17.05   17.52    4.03    0.11
               EXACT    45   27.14    7.43   11.35    1.54   -0.42   30.24   -0.06   19.71   20.29   22.77   11.43    0.09
   311   1hr   B-FIT    49   16.27    9.60    7.64    6.41    0.53   11.14    0.45    6.67    7.29    9.94    7.40    0.57
               EXACT    49   18.10    9.60    7.98    6.41    0.47   13.61    0.38    8.51    9.30   11.72    8.10    0.48
        24hr   B-FIT    45   16.85    8.50    3.23    1.11   -1.79   32.01   -0.61    8.35    8.35    9.24    3.96    0.09
               EXACT    45   18.17    8.50    8.33    1.11    0.63   12.82    0.08    9.67   10.89   12.69    8.31    0.14
   416   1hr   B-FIT    49   22.41    9.63   10.69    5.03    1.62    6.81    0.76   12.79   12.79   14.83    7.51    0.47
               EXACT    49   30.60    9.63   17.95    5.03    2.67    4.92    0.75   20.98   20.98   25.46   14.43    0.33
        24hr   B-FIT    45   20.04    8.32    4.76    2.17    2.10    2.54    0.96   11.72   11.72   12.03    2.72    0.31
               EXACT    45   31.53    8.32   18.43    2.17    5.97  -18.12    0.70   23.21   23.21   28.64   16.78    0.16
   572   1hr   B-FIT    49   17.88    8.00    8.51    4.95    1.21    8.20    0.70    9.88   10.17   11.60    6.08    0.51
               EXACT    49   22.09    8.00    8.85    4.95    1.10   13.31    0.61   14.09   14.43   15.70    6.93    0.39
        24hr   B-FIT    45   16.04    7.37    4.01    1.44    0.94    9.09    0.34    8.67    8.67    9.44    3.73    0.21
               EXACT    45   22.62    7.37    9.00    1.44    0.11   21.84    0.02   15.25   15.25   17.71    8.99    0.11
  1034   1hr   B-FIT    49   10.48    7.58    5.59    3.69    1.24    1.07    0.82    2.90    2.95    4.39    3.30    0.78
               EXACT    49   12.13    7.58    6.27    3.69    1.22    2.88    0.72    4.55    4.68    6.32    4.39    0.64
        24hr   B-FIT    45    7.98    5.87    4.00    2.08    1.91   -3.20    0.99    2.11    2.12    2.87    1.94    0.80
               EXACT    45   12.79    5.87    6.11    2.08    2.08    0.60    0.71    6.92    6.92    8.43    4.82    0.38