Model Performance Evaluation (MPE) PM2.5 d12 (2009010200-2009010400)
CAMSID AVG METHOD NDATA MEAN_M MEAN_O STDDEV_M STDDEV_O SLOPE OFFSET R G_BIAS G_ERR G_RMSE G_SDE IOA
Total B-FIT 1680 11.22 10.06 7.06 4.97 0.75 3.63 0.53 1.16 3.76 6.22 6.64 0.70
EXACT 1680 13.15 10.06 9.87 4.97 0.68 6.35 0.34 3.09 7.00 9.91 10.19 0.50
d12h B-FIT 645 7.35 7.52 3.85 3.33 0.54 3.26 0.47 -0.17 2.11 3.72 4.36 0.70
EXACT 645 9.12 7.52 6.86 3.33 0.45 5.77 0.22 1.60 5.12 7.12 7.78 0.43
d12d B-FIT 342 15.52 10.71 8.50 5.11 0.55 9.65 0.33 4.81 6.51 9.62 8.51 0.50
EXACT 342 18.05 10.71 11.11 5.11 0.38 14.02 0.17 7.34 9.88 13.54 11.66 0.34
1 1hr B-FIT 8 10.43 9.42 1.85 2.24 0.77 3.18 0.93 1.01 1.02 1.28 0.78 0.89
EXACT 8 16.42 9.42 4.94 2.24 1.14 5.70 0.52 7.00 7.00 8.05 3.97 0.36
24hr B-FIT 4 9.32 9.46 0.56 0.35 1.58 -5.62 0.98 -0.14 0.23 0.24 0.41 0.91
EXACT 4 16.13 9.46 1.01 0.35 0.72 9.33 0.25 6.67 6.67 6.72 0.85 0.06
3 1hr B-FIT 49 15.24 13.62 6.16 4.80 0.67 6.04 0.53 1.61 3.52 5.64 5.73 0.72
EXACT 49 17.54 13.62 8.96 4.80 0.53 10.29 0.29 3.92 6.72 9.62 9.22 0.50
24hr B-FIT 45 14.60 14.63 2.39 2.11 0.94 0.89 0.83 -0.02 0.90 1.33 1.62 0.90
EXACT 45 17.40 14.63 9.32 2.11 -1.64 41.36 -0.37 2.77 9.06 10.55 11.96 0.04
4 1hr B-FIT 49 7.11 9.92 3.10 5.08 0.43 2.80 0.71 -2.80 2.90 4.54 6.73 0.74
EXACT 49 8.75 9.92 3.70 5.08 0.18 6.95 0.25 -1.17 4.30 5.56 7.71 0.55
24hr B-FIT 45 8.25 11.84 2.55 4.01 0.58 1.42 0.91 -3.59 3.59 4.10 7.45 0.73
EXACT 45 8.35 11.84 3.59 4.01 -0.34 12.44 -0.38 -3.48 6.28 7.16 11.60 0.23
8 1hr B-FIT 49 10.56 8.33 4.59 3.31 0.46 6.69 0.34 2.23 3.47 5.13 4.79 0.53
EXACT 49 13.07 8.33 7.52 3.31 0.19 11.48 0.08 4.74 7.09 9.19 8.22 0.27
24hr B-FIT 45 10.53 8.87 1.98 2.00 -0.03 10.83 -0.03 1.66 2.04 3.28 2.85 0.43
EXACT 45 13.03 8.87 7.84 2.00 -3.10 40.57 -0.79 4.16 8.15 10.27 10.21 0.01
15 1hr B-FIT 49 7.98 7.36 3.18 3.26 0.54 4.00 0.55 0.62 1.83 3.08 3.25 0.76
EXACT 49 9.81 7.36 5.61 3.26 -0.02 9.94 -0.01 2.44 5.35 6.89 7.07 0.36
24hr B-FIT 45 7.86 7.64 1.56 1.76 0.84 1.46 0.95 0.22 0.43 0.60 0.60 0.97
EXACT 45 9.78 7.64 5.85 1.76 -2.47 28.67 -0.74 2.14 6.08 7.49 8.19 0.02
23 1hr B-FIT 49 15.12 13.81 4.68 3.88 0.76 4.63 0.63 1.32 2.77 3.94 3.99 0.78
EXACT 49 19.50 13.81 10.03 3.88 -0.23 22.61 -0.09 5.69 8.95 12.34 11.43 0.23
24hr B-FIT 45 15.12 14.98 2.17 2.13 0.92 1.35 0.91 0.14 0.53 0.94 1.01 0.95
EXACT 45 19.39 14.98 10.47 2.13 -1.87 47.36 -0.38 4.41 9.56 12.15 12.44 0.04
35 1hr B-FIT 49 6.43 6.70 2.19 2.61 0.29 4.46 0.35 -0.26 1.56 2.75 3.28 0.64
EXACT 49 8.56 6.70 5.13 2.61 -0.27 10.40 -0.14 1.87 4.87 6.30 6.72 0.27
24hr B-FIT 45 7.01 7.21 1.34 1.66 0.74 1.66 0.92 -0.20 0.50 0.70 0.97 0.94
EXACT 45 8.51 7.21 5.35 1.66 -2.55 26.88 -0.79 1.30 5.64 6.80 7.96 0.02
38 1hr B-FIT 49 14.02 11.34 5.70 3.14 0.43 9.16 0.24 2.68 3.85 6.36 5.88 0.49
EXACT 49 13.62 11.34 7.25 3.14 0.42 8.87 0.18 2.28 5.56 7.63 7.99 0.42
24hr B-FIT 45 13.24 12.31 2.24 1.77 0.77 3.81 0.60 0.93 1.01 2.03 1.81 0.75
EXACT 45 13.46 12.31 7.55 1.77 -1.61 33.32 -0.38 1.15 7.09 8.36 10.20 0.06
45 1hr B-FIT 49 6.08 6.55 2.03 2.47 0.36 3.70 0.44 -0.47 1.37 2.42 3.00 0.69
EXACT 49 5.45 6.55 3.11 2.47 -0.28 7.26 -0.22 -1.10 3.25 4.46 6.14 0.35
24hr B-FIT 45 6.92 7.04 1.40 1.68 0.77 1.51 0.92 -0.12 0.49 0.67 0.90 0.95
EXACT 45 5.37 7.04 3.23 1.68 -1.67 17.14 -0.87 -1.67 4.53 5.00 7.79 0.03
52 1hr B-FIT 49 14.62 11.15 8.41 3.43 0.38 10.38 0.16 3.47 5.61 9.17 8.75 0.39
EXACT 49 15.85 11.15 10.59 3.43 0.00 15.80 0.00 4.70 8.28 11.98 11.59 0.28
24hr B-FIT 45 12.62 12.04 2.68 0.77 -0.45 18.01 -0.13 0.57 1.96 2.91 3.17 0.24
EXACT 45 15.93 12.04 11.04 0.77 -8.50 118.36 -0.59 3.89 9.35 12.03 12.62 0.02
56 1hr B-FIT 49 17.10 10.86 8.66 7.75 0.69 9.56 0.62 6.23 7.74 9.46 7.28 0.69
EXACT 49 20.88 10.86 11.57 7.75 0.56 14.79 0.38 10.01 11.87 14.97 11.29 0.47
24hr B-FIT 45 14.00 9.96 6.55 4.85 1.22 1.89 0.90 4.04 4.05 5.03 3.00 0.82
EXACT 45 21.76 9.96 11.67 4.85 1.83 3.56 0.76 11.79 11.79 14.53 8.49 0.46
59 1hr B-FIT 49 13.55 12.26 5.82 4.45 0.76 4.28 0.58 1.30 3.59 4.99 5.34 0.75
EXACT 49 15.09 12.26 8.00 4.45 0.57 8.12 0.32 2.83 6.92 8.25 8.76 0.51
24hr B-FIT 45 13.19 13.29 2.61 2.90 0.66 4.37 0.74 -0.10 1.52 2.00 2.57 0.86
EXACT 45 15.14 13.29 8.35 2.90 -1.94 40.94 -0.68 1.85 9.48 10.57 12.90 0.05
60 1hr B-FIT 49 16.92 9.08 9.47 3.92 0.63 11.21 0.26 7.84 7.92 12.06 9.16 0.35
EXACT 49 23.93 9.08 13.80 3.92 1.00 14.85 0.28 14.85 14.85 19.80 13.10 0.26
24hr B-FIT 45 13.68 9.45 5.10 1.10 2.53 -10.18 0.55 4.23 4.25 6.21 4.54 0.25
EXACT 45 24.62 9.45 14.20 1.10 3.86 -11.89 0.30 15.17 15.65 20.47 13.76 0.07
61 1hr B-FIT 48 14.83 9.38 8.60 3.57 0.49 10.23 0.20 5.45 6.24 10.11 8.56 0.36
EXACT 48 15.50 9.38 9.85 3.57 0.25 13.14 0.09 6.12 8.18 11.78 10.27 0.30
24hr B-FIT 45 12.45 10.01 3.27 0.82 0.01 12.31 0.00 2.44 2.51 4.13 3.33 0.22
EXACT 45 15.63 10.01 10.14 0.82 -2.67 42.35 -0.22 5.62 8.43 11.68 10.62 0.06
64 1hr B-FIT 49 3.54 5.51 2.28 4.15 -0.00 3.54 -0.00 -1.97 2.92 5.09 6.78 0.40
EXACT 49 4.21 5.51 3.10 4.15 -0.08 4.68 -0.11 -1.30 3.80 5.55 7.43 0.31
24hr B-FIT 45 2.71 6.08 0.84 1.71 -0.43 5.33 -0.88 -3.36 3.36 4.16 7.16 0.31
EXACT 45 4.30 6.08 3.21 1.71 -1.51 13.47 -0.80 -1.78 4.44 4.97 7.76 0.07
71 1hr B-FIT 49 15.69 11.41 9.08 3.36 0.52 9.71 0.19 4.28 7.41 9.93 9.49 0.35
EXACT 49 16.73 11.41 10.23 3.36 0.63 9.49 0.21 5.32 8.98 11.31 10.63 0.33
24hr B-FIT 45 12.40 11.92 5.04 0.84 -0.13 13.91 -0.02 0.49 4.06 5.09 6.20 0.12
EXACT 45 17.05 11.92 10.62 0.84 -4.90 75.42 -0.39 5.14 10.10 12.00 11.93 0.01
78 1hr B-FIT 49 9.72 7.81 4.51 3.18 0.48 5.96 0.34 1.91 2.76 4.90 4.59 0.57
EXACT 49 12.18 7.81 6.88 3.18 0.33 9.62 0.15 4.37 5.58 8.30 7.15 0.35
24hr B-FIT 45 9.69 8.18 1.84 2.08 0.26 7.57 0.29 1.51 1.95 2.76 2.35 0.57
EXACT 45 12.24 8.18 7.18 2.08 -2.02 28.79 -0.59 4.06 6.97 9.39 8.95 0.01
85 1hr B-FIT 49 11.01 11.05 6.57 3.49 1.18 -2.08 0.63 -0.04 3.97 5.10 6.49 0.70
EXACT 49 11.01 11.05 7.79 3.49 1.26 -2.93 0.56 -0.05 5.46 6.43 8.46 0.62
24hr B-FIT 45 7.71 10.31 4.30 1.34 1.55 -8.25 0.48 -2.60 3.77 4.59 7.40 0.45
EXACT 45 11.68 10.31 7.78 1.34 0.82 3.24 0.14 1.37 6.70 7.74 9.30 0.25
301 1hr B-FIT 49 16.59 13.45 5.57 3.97 0.61 8.35 0.44 3.15 4.20 6.07 5.29 0.63
EXACT 49 21.10 13.45 9.72 3.97 0.72 11.40 0.29 7.66 9.23 12.02 9.39 0.39
24hr B-FIT 45 16.05 14.57 3.08 2.60 0.64 6.75 0.54 1.47 1.68 3.11 2.74 0.71
EXACT 45 21.20 14.57 10.15 2.60 -1.86 48.34 -0.48 6.62 10.99 13.26 12.29 0.09
303 1hr B-FIT 49 5.47 7.16 3.04 3.31 0.64 0.90 0.69 -1.69 1.76 3.00 4.25 0.79
EXACT 49 5.31 7.16 3.21 3.31 0.37 2.65 0.38 -1.85 2.84 4.04 5.90 0.61
24hr B-FIT 45 4.77 6.87 1.30 1.24 -0.35 7.19 -0.34 -2.09 2.15 2.93 4.71 0.33
EXACT 45 5.45 6.87 3.31 1.24 -1.20 13.68 -0.45 -1.42 3.52 4.23 6.35 0.15
304 1hr B-FIT 49 8.78 9.29 3.48 3.68 0.76 1.72 0.80 -0.51 1.17 2.29 2.79 0.89
EXACT 49 11.93 9.29 6.28 3.68 0.59 6.44 0.35 2.64 5.46 6.57 6.64 0.56
24hr B-FIT 45 9.06 9.36 1.25 1.60 0.71 2.43 0.91 -0.30 0.51 0.75 1.06 0.93
EXACT 45 11.82 9.36 6.53 1.60 -3.03 40.17 -0.74 2.45 6.33 8.09 8.63 0.02
309 1hr B-FIT 49 11.02 9.75 4.54 2.90 0.55 5.66 0.35 1.27 2.82 4.58 4.67 0.58
EXACT 49 17.16 9.75 9.46 2.90 0.61 11.22 0.19 7.41 9.03 11.87 9.41 0.25
24hr B-FIT 45 10.40 9.88 1.60 1.91 0.50 5.49 0.59 0.52 1.32 1.67 1.78 0.75
EXACT 45 17.24 9.88 9.87 1.91 -3.64 53.17 -0.70 7.36 9.97 13.38 11.47 0.02
310 1hr B-FIT 49 14.93 12.95 6.93 7.29 0.54 7.92 0.57 1.97 4.76 6.84 7.11 0.73
EXACT 49 16.81 12.95 8.22 7.29 0.29 13.02 0.26 3.86 8.35 10.14 10.40 0.53
24hr B-FIT 45 13.19 14.03 2.37 2.42 0.08 12.00 0.09 -0.85 2.50 3.31 4.63 0.38
EXACT 45 17.43 14.03 8.30 2.42 -1.15 33.53 -0.33 3.39 8.53 9.88 10.61 0.08
311 1hr B-FIT 49 6.67 8.88 3.17 2.92 0.33 3.74 0.30 -2.21 2.50 4.19 5.90 0.58
EXACT 49 6.46 8.88 4.16 2.92 0.20 4.67 0.14 -2.42 3.98 5.27 7.93 0.47
24hr B-FIT 45 5.40 8.91 1.86 1.58 -0.81 12.64 -0.69 -3.51 3.54 4.71 7.72 0.23
EXACT 45 6.78 8.91 4.19 1.58 -2.01 24.71 -0.76 -2.14 5.03 5.83 8.99 0.07
313 1hr B-FIT 49 12.23 15.29 4.49 6.04 0.46 5.18 0.62 -3.06 4.02 5.65 8.53 0.70
EXACT 49 12.11 15.29 5.45 6.04 0.04 11.47 0.05 -3.19 7.06 8.49 12.92 0.39
24hr B-FIT 45 11.64 16.71 2.60 2.27 -0.29 16.54 -0.26 -5.08 5.13 6.35 10.90 0.29
EXACT 45 12.27 16.71 5.60 2.27 -1.97 45.20 -0.80 -4.45 6.48 8.68 13.22 0.07
314 1hr B-FIT 49 3.46 8.48 2.03 4.65 0.21 1.72 0.47 -5.02 5.08 6.46 10.89 0.54
EXACT 49 2.05 8.48 1.17 4.65 0.05 1.63 0.20 -6.43 6.51 7.86 13.71 0.47
24hr B-FIT 45 4.03 10.43 1.51 3.30 0.37 0.19 0.81 -6.40 6.40 6.78 12.99 0.49
EXACT 45 1.84 10.43 0.96 3.30 -0.06 2.41 -0.19 -8.59 8.59 9.30 17.54 0.36
315 1hr B-FIT 49 11.51 5.71 9.23 3.17 0.71 7.45 0.24 5.79 6.40 10.63 8.93 0.30
EXACT 49 13.93 5.71 12.43 3.17 0.50 11.06 0.13 8.22 9.43 14.79 12.36 0.19
24hr B-FIT 45 8.09 5.63 4.41 0.90 1.63 -1.07 0.33 2.46 2.64 4.82 4.15 0.19
EXACT 45 14.65 5.63 12.73 0.90 -0.75 18.89 -0.05 9.02 10.33 15.55 12.73 0.02
416 1hr B-FIT 49 8.06 7.37 2.73 2.29 0.26 6.12 0.22 0.69 1.85 3.20 3.33 0.53
EXACT 49 13.73 7.37 5.96 2.29 -0.76 19.37 -0.29 6.36 7.67 9.40 7.04 0.12
24hr B-FIT 45 8.33 8.00 1.46 1.76 0.72 2.54 0.88 0.34 0.56 0.91 0.87 0.92
EXACT 45 13.66 8.00 6.22 1.76 -3.01 37.74 -0.85 5.66 6.96 9.55 7.80 0.06
572 1hr B-FIT 49 6.24 6.58 2.22 2.38 0.29 4.35 0.31 -0.34 1.62 2.70 3.32 0.61
EXACT 49 6.49 6.58 3.97 2.38 -0.30 8.47 -0.18 -0.09 3.71 4.93 6.22 0.29
24hr B-FIT 45 6.93 6.97 1.33 1.47 0.82 1.20 0.91 -0.04 0.48 0.61 0.80 0.95
EXACT 45 6.42 6.97 4.14 1.47 -2.34 22.70 -0.83 -0.55 4.72 5.38 7.51 0.01
601 1hr B-FIT 49 8.78 10.04 4.39 3.13 0.45 4.25 0.32 -1.26 3.68 4.63 6.65 0.57
EXACT 49 9.61 10.04 7.12 3.13 0.47 4.87 0.21 -0.44 6.06 7.10 9.61 0.42
24hr B-FIT 45 7.71 10.86 1.78 2.30 0.16 5.98 0.21 -3.14 3.26 4.06 6.90 0.42
EXACT 45 9.57 10.86 7.43 2.30 -1.97 30.91 -0.61 -1.28 8.21 9.00 13.02 0.07
622 1hr B-FIT 49 14.29 12.94 5.43 4.50 0.86 3.15 0.71 1.35 2.74 4.06 4.07 0.82
EXACT 49 18.05 12.94 9.81 4.50 0.78 8.01 0.36 5.11 8.02 10.46 9.58 0.43
24hr B-FIT 45 14.16 13.88 2.95 3.26 0.83 2.71 0.91 0.28 0.90 1.35 1.46 0.95
EXACT 45 18.21 13.88 10.22 3.26 -1.87 44.11 -0.59 4.32 10.86 13.03 13.92 0.06
676 1hr B-FIT 41 15.75 15.70 5.95 4.75 0.85 2.41 0.68 0.05 3.12 4.37 5.34 0.80
EXACT 41 15.83 15.70 8.62 4.75 0.69 4.98 0.38 0.13 6.71 8.01 10.36 0.53
24hr B-FIT 45 15.82 16.45 2.56 2.71 0.65 5.09 0.69 -0.63 1.80 2.15 3.19 0.82
EXACT 45 16.94 16.45 8.77 2.71 -1.46 41.04 -0.45 0.49 8.61 10.19 13.02 0.04
677 1hr B-FIT 15 22.14 13.62 4.59 4.25 0.51 15.22 0.47 8.52 8.52 9.59 4.40 0.44
EXACT 15 31.22 13.62 10.42 4.25 0.82 20.05 0.33 17.60 17.60 20.01 9.51 0.25
24hr B-FIT 11 20.10 12.20 2.40 1.00 2.07 -5.14 0.86 7.90 7.90 8.04 1.54 0.16
EXACT 11 34.02 12.20 10.67 1.00 -4.95 94.38 -0.47 21.81 21.81 24.27 10.65 0.03
678 1hr B-FIT 49 16.81 15.83 6.28 5.28 0.64 6.67 0.54 0.98 3.75 5.65 6.22 0.73
EXACT 49 19.72 15.83 12.04 5.28 0.79 7.25 0.35 3.90 8.37 11.89 12.09 0.47
24hr B-FIT 45 16.25 16.01 2.95 2.52 0.90 1.78 0.77 0.25 1.38 1.88 2.18 0.87
EXACT 45 19.81 16.01 12.56 2.52 -1.81 48.70 -0.36 3.80 10.70 14.05 15.19 0.03
1034 1hr B-FIT 49 4.45 6.16 1.52 3.72 0.22 3.07 0.55 -1.71 1.97 3.56 4.83 0.58
EXACT 49 2.97 6.16 1.21 3.72 0.01 2.92 0.02 -3.19 3.64 5.00 7.84 0.44
24hr B-FIT 45 4.86 7.17 0.63 2.25 0.16 3.73 0.56 -2.30 2.42 3.02 5.11 0.55
EXACT 45 2.90 7.17 1.25 2.25 -0.28 4.92 -0.51 -4.26 4.47 5.24 9.25 0.31
1037 1hr B-FIT 49 14.55 10.12 8.21 3.22 0.68 7.65 0.27 4.42 5.88 9.05 8.03 0.39
EXACT 49 16.64 10.12 10.64 3.22 0.46 12.00 0.14 6.51 8.61 12.41 10.77 0.26
24hr B-FIT 45 12.36 10.83 3.88 1.53 0.43 7.71 0.17 1.54 2.95 4.17 4.13 0.29
EXACT 45 16.81 10.83 11.08 1.53 -2.51 43.94 -0.35 5.98 10.27 13.03 12.34 0.01